Skip to content
Submit Your Story
Culture

What If Writers of Color Are Just Often Better?

By Frederick Joseph • October 25, 2026

My mother instructed me to return home before nightfall.

Mama said I better be in that house ’fore it got dark.

Mom wanted me home with the last of the daylight still on my clothes.

My moms said I better be in the crib before it’s dark or she gonna be tight.

These are four versions of an ordinary sentence: formal English, Southern vernacular, and a sentence leaning into the lyricism of poetry, and Northeast Black vernacular. Other than the last one, no race owns them. But a writer who can hear and use all four is armed with a pen that a writer confined to one is not.

Keep this pen in mind. Because it is this tool–this ability to be a switch-hitter–which makes someone such as myself a better writer than someone such as Bret Stephens.

In his New York Times opinion column “The Literary World’s D.E.I. Checklist,” (which I’m not linking to, because I’m not going to give him or the New York Times any more clicks for that bullshit) Bret argues that major literary awards increasingly reward marginalized identities and subjects rather than literary merit. He takes inventory of the backgrounds of this year’s National Book Award nominees, identifies the racial backgrounds of Pulitzer-winners, and presents a list as evidence of a corrupted standard. He does acknowledge that some of the books are excellent. He doesn’t establish which supposedly better books were passed over, or how the winners’ identities helped the award committees.

As a Black author reading his column, I was especially interested in a possibility he simply didn’t consider: what if writers of color are just often better?

This is a question about preparation, experience, and inheritance. To the last point–it’s important to understand that no one inherits a good sentence through their skin. But talent does arrive at the desk carrying everything a writer has learned to notice, and the world has never required the same attentiveness from everyone.I know this all too well.

In my first book, The Black Friend, I wrote about attending a largely white high school, where even my interest in Star Wars provoked surprise from my white classmates. People can imagine distant galaxies and still find a Black boy’s enjoyment of them unexpected. The assumption was that my Blackness should have kept me at a distance from something mainstream dominant culture had already put in front of me. It had not. I can write about the television shows 7th Heaven and How I Met Your Mother. I can write about Joni Mitchell and Pink Floyd. None of this requires me to leave my Blackness at the door. Which is why my imagination still has room for D’Angelo and Teddy Pendergrass, for Living Single and Boyz N the Hood, for the different kinds of laughter, comfort, loneliness, foolishness, tenderness, and desire these works make available.

Can Bret, or most white writers, move through worlds such as those with comparable intimacy? Can he write about the Fourth of July with the same understanding as the Lunar New Year? Can he muse on the taste of kofta as he can the taste of green bean casserole? I don’t know his listening habits, and my argument doesn’t require him to fail a quiz. I’m asking whether knowledge of D’Angelo counts as cultural literacy to the same degree as knowledge of Pink Floyd. Whether unfamiliarity with Living Single registers as a gap in one’s education or merely as proof that the show was not intended for certain people.

There is a considerable difference between having something available to you and knowing you have to learn from it.

For many of us, white mainstream culture was never an elective. It was at school, on television, in the references other people expected us to understand. Our own cultural lives continued parallel to it. We learned to recognize ourselves in work that barely recognized us, without abandoning the work in which we recognized our people. This is one of white supremacy’s cultural contradictions: it demands a broader education from those it marginalizes than from those it places at the center.

That education isn’t just an impressive collection of references. Knowing the names of musicians across various races won’t rescue a shitty paragraph. The advantage, when a writer develops it, lies in the movement between worlds: the ear for shifts in tone, the awareness of various audiences, the ability to recognize how a single sentence can mean one thing to the writer and something else to the reader who has or hasn’t survived its context.

Consider a child listening to her mother answer a call from work, then a call from her sister. The child hears the voice, tone, register change. She notices what words come easily, which laughter sounds rehearsed versus coming from the diaphragm until your cheeks hurt. Before she knows the term code switching, she has begun studying it.

A writer can cast infinite spells with that sort of knowledge.

W. E. B. Du Bois described the “double-consciousness” of Black Americans: the traumatic experience of seeing oneself through the eyes of a world that hates you. He was describing a division in the self, not advertising the benefits of suffering. But his account helps illuminate the attention I mean. The knowledge that your understanding of yourself and someone else’s interpretation of you can occupy the same room without ever meeting. This sort of knowledge can be an education in perspective. It gives a writer something to work with when needing to craft a singular truth for readers of various backgrounds.

This doesn’t make white supremacy a gift. I would gladly trade any artistic advantage purchased through white supremacy for a world without the white supremacy. People lose time, confidence, opportunities, whole unwritten books to it. This also doesn’t mean every writer of color possesses the same repertoire. A Haitian American novelist, an indigenous American storyteller, and a Korean American writer don’t arrive carrying interchangeable worlds. Bret’s myopic view of marginalized writers obscures precisely the differences that make reading them worthwhile.

I mean, look at what happens in his own column.

Alexander Maksik’s (white man) book Passengers receives the comprehensible description of a father-daughter story. While Julián Delgado Lopera’s (person of color) Pretend You’re Dead and I Carry You is introduced through its exploration of Colombia’s queer underground. Yet the National Book Foundation’s announcement also describes Delgado Lopera’s novel as a story about a father and daughter learning to live together after the mother’s death. Similar spine centering family, but Bret’s summaries don’t give them equal attention. A father and daughter can become evidence of an everyday human experience in one entry and disappear behind a demographic description in another. A critic who reduces distinct books to their authors’ identities hasn’t demonstrated that the books lack range. He’s demonstrated the limits of his range.

I’m not asking him to admire any marginalized author out of courtesy (I know Traci Thomas loves to hear this). Literary courtesy can be its own humiliation. Read us seriously enough to dislike us precisely. Tell us where the language lacks, where a character becomes flat, where a conclusion evades what the book has spent its pages leading us to. Bring another book into the argument and show what it does better. That would be criticism worth answering.

There’s also room to question the awards themselves. The National Book Foundation says its judging panels develop their own criteria and deliberate independently (Why y’all don’t like my work?! Kidding–sort of.). Such a process can be challenged on questions of taste, fashion, or judgment. Nothing about a prize places it beyond criticism. But the identity of a winner cannot do the work of demonstrating a failure of judgment.

Bret asks readers to worry that excellence has been displaced. My question is whether his account of excellence is large enough to recognize all the ways it might arrive.

Take two equally gifted, equally disciplined writers. Give one a more practiced eye for several worlds, a wider store of cultural references, and years of experience interpreting people who misunderstand them. Why would we assume those differences disappear when the writing begins? Why would the ability to do more with language be treated as an unfair advantage rather than part of the work? A white writer can acquire range. Many do. A writer of color can fail to acquire it, or fail to make anything worthwhile from it. The point is that range must be acquired, and a life organized around crossing boundaries best furnishes a page.

Perhaps then, the people Bret regards as beneficiaries of a lowered standard have been preparing, for years, to meet a more demanding one he has never had to.

******

P.S. I wasn’t going to write about that foolish man until he came on my radar because of Robert Jones, Jr. and Kiese Laymon. I have books to be focused on man, ha.

Frederick Joseph
Website | + posts

2 X NYT and USA Today Bestselling Author | ILA Book Award Winner | 📚 This Thing of Ours (Preorder now), We Alive, Beloved, Patriarchy Blues, Wakanda Forever: The Courage to Dream, Better Than We Found It, The Black Friend | IG: FredTJoseph

More in Culture

Verified by MonsterInsights